Subsidiary Circles of Philosophy

There are three basic subdivisions in philosophy: epistemology, metaphysics, and ethics. You can take these 3 subdivisions of the philosophy questionnaire to see whether your overall score matches the score for the subdivisions.

Perhaps your views vary within the different categories. For example, do you solve problems by thinking, and look for rational answers when seeking knowledge, but think ethical principles are relative and rely on your feelings instead to guide your life? In other words, are you a rationalist overall, but in ethics more existential or relativist? Or vice-versa? Do you follow spiritual methods of knowing, but don't believe in God or spirits? Or vice-versa?

Below are three smaller versions of the questionnaire for each division of philosophy-- epistemology, metaphysics and ethics, and the scoring and subsidiary circle for each. It is probably easiest to print each set of questions before answering them.

Answer strongly agree, somewhat agree, yes and no/neutral, somewhat disagree, or strongly disagree to each question.


Epistemology (theory of knowledge)

This area of philosophy concerns how we know what we know. What is the best way to discover the truth? What methods should be used? How can things be explained? To find out your views about epistemology, answer these questions, and then score your answers below, just like you did for the overall test.

1. The Heart has its reasons, which Reason does not know.

2. The senses cannot be trusted to give us the truth.

3. There is a rational explanation for everything, since events are produced according to physical laws.

5. Reason leads us to discover the general truths and ideas that explain all existing things.

6. If you would know the truth of life, look inward into yourself.

9. Reality is fluid and ever-changing; thus forever beyond the grasp of the rigid, abstract concepts & categories of our thought and language.

13. Spirit or mind creates the world, and all our science can only describe the effects after-the-fact.

14. Faith is unreliable; we’d better trust to what we know

16. All knowledge is based on experience and observation; rational theories alone are only meaningless abstractions.

23. Human consciousness and behavior can be fully explained in terms of the electro-chemistry of the brain and nervous system.

24. As Plato proved, a child has innate knowledge of mathematics; therefore eternal and rational truths exist.

25. Human history is largely explanable in terms of economic and technological conditions.

27. Science will eventually give us most of the answers to what seems uncertain to us today.

29. Mathematics is probably one of the closest things to truth you can find.

30. Seeing is believing; whatever can’t be touched, observed or tested experimentally probably doesn’t exist.

31. By transcending the delusions of your thinking mind, you discover that you are not a separate ego, but are one with a greater being.

Indicate your answers here by circling your score for each question in the appropriate box. Where two scores are listed, circle both.
strongly agree somewhat agree yes&no/neutral somewhat disagree strongly disagree
1. 4E  2S 2E  1S 2R  1M 4R  2M
2. 3R  2S 2R  1S 2E  1M 3E  2M
3. 3R  3M 2R  2M 2E  2S 3E  3S
5. 4R  2R 2E 4E
6. 1E  4S 1E  2S 1R  2M 1R  4M
9. 4E 2E 2R 4R
13.     4S       2S       2M       4M
14.3R 2M 2R  1M 2E  1S 3E  2S
16.4E 2E 2R 4R
23.      4M       2M        2S       4S
24.4R 2R 2E 4E
25.      4M       2M        2S       4S
27.2R  4M 1R  2M 1E  2S 2E  4S
29.4R 2R 2E 4E
30.2E  3M 1E  2M 1R  2S 2R  3S
31.2E  4S 1E  2S 1R  2M 2R  4M

Add your circled scores here:
___E ___S ___E ___S ___E ___S ___E ___S
___R ___M ___R ___M ___R ___M ___R ___M

Then add all the E scores across the columns above  _______
Then all the S scores ________
Then all the R scores ________
Then all the M scores ________

Write the larger letter scores above the smaller letter scores here:
 
          E and R           S and M
          _______          ________
 minus _______ minus ________
equals _______ equals ________
Write the letter corresponding to the larger score next to the result. The left column is your E/R score and the right column is your S/M score.

For example:
 
        E and R         S and M
           30E            20S
minus  20R minus  10M
equals 10E equals  10S

The meaning of the scores: what is your theory of knowledge?
1-13 R = somewhat intellectual; In your approach to knowledge, you rely on reason and distrust feelings and experiences
14-26 R = definitely intellectual
27-41 R = extremely intellectual
1-13 E = somewhat experiential;  You rely on your experience more than reason
14-26 E = definitely experiential
27-41 E = extremely experiential
1-12 S = somewhat spiritualist;   You rely on spiritual methods to explain things
13-24 S = definitely spiritualist
25-36 S = extremely spiritualist
1-12 M = somewhat materialist;  You rely on physical methods to explain things
13-24 M = definitely materialist
25-36 M = extremely materialist

If you are R and S, you are essentialist: universal ideas and divine archetypes are the source of knowledge
If you are R and M, you are rationalist: Truth is found through knowledge of causal, logical laws
If you are E and S, you are existentialist: experience of the spontaneous flux of inner being is the best source of knowledge
If you are E and M, you are empiricist: sense experience and experimental results determines truth

The approach to epistemology (theory of knowledge) shown by your score matches these Jungian functions and MBTI temperaments, although your temperament itself may be different:

R/S essentialist = N intuitive
R/M rationalist = T thinking
E/S existentialist = F feeling
E/M empiricist = S sensing

Your epistemology score places you in one of 32 quadrants. A circle can be drawn around them. This is the subsidiary Circle of Epistemology. Here I will only show the quadrants. Imagine a circle around them.

I have used most of the same 2 defining keywords for each quadrant as in the overall circle, and shown philosophers and traditions who I think may occupy them (positions are necessarily approximate). The quadrants in the opposite positions to each other, and same distance from the center, have opposite and complementary meanings.
 
25-36S
14-27R
Asceticism
Abstraction
Augustine
25-36S
0-13R
Esoterics
Revelation
Metaphysics
Plotinus
25-36S
0-13E
Spiritism
Psychism
Mysticism
Jesus
25-36S
14-27E
Transcendence
Solipcism
Berkeley
Kierkegaard
13-24S
27-41R
Essence
Forms
Plato
Pythagoras
13-24S
14-26R
Truth
Eternal values
Principles
Classicism
Leibniz
13-24S
0-13R
Theology
Theosophy
Hegel
Aquinas
Kant
13-24S
0-13E
Aspiration
Faith
Jung
Teilhard de Chardin
Buddha
13-24S
14-26E
Awareness
Awe
Romanticism
Schopenhauer
James
Alan Watts
Jos.Campbell
13-24S
27-41E
Existence
Becoming
Bergson
Heidegger
Heraclitus
0-12S
27-41R
Order
Doctrine
Parmenides
Spinoza
0-12S
14-26R
Purpose
Ideals
Epictetus
Stoicism
Aristotle
0-12S
0-13R
Theory
Ideas
Whitehead
0-12S
0-13E
Reverence
NatureWorship
Pantheists
Neo-pagans
Quantum Theory
0-12S
14-26E
Flux
Adventure
Authenticity
0-12S
27-41E
Nihilism
Absurdity
Nietzsche
Sartre
0-12M
27-41R
Formulae
Mathematics
Descartes
0-12M
14-26R
Calculation
Structure
Empedocles
0-12M
0-13R
Explanation
Manipulation
Voltaire
Einstein
G.E.Moore
0-12M
0-13E
Pragmatism
Utilitarianism
Mill
Bentham
Anaxagoras
0-12M
14-26E
Relativism
Chance
Skeptics
0-12M
27-41E
Chaos
Iconoclasm
Nominalism
Hume
13-24M
27-41R
Logic
Geometry
Euclid
13-24M
14-26R
Natural Law
Reliability
Mechanics
Hawking
 
13-24M
0-13R
Prediction
Engineering
Freud
Russell
Marx
Santayana
13-24M
0-13E
Verification
Secularism
Experiment
Dewey
Carnap
13-24M
14-26E
Sophism
Evidence
Epicureans
13-24M
27-41E
Sense-
Perception
Locke
Wittgenstein--
(later years)
25-36M
14-27R
Necessity
Automism
Newtonian-- Physics
25-36M
0-13R
Atomism
Determinism
Hobbes
Democritus
25-36M
0-13E
Positivism
Objectivism
Darwin
Lucretius
25-36M
14-27E
Tangibility
Carnality
Bacon
Skinner


Metaphysics (Ultimates) This area of philosophy concerns ultimate reality and the foundation of things. Where did the universe come from, and how did I get here? (cosmology) What is the nature of being? (ontology) What is real, and what is an illusion? (metaphysics) To find out your views about metaphysics, answer these questions, and then score your answers below, just like you did for the overall test.
Answer strongly agree, somewhat agree, yes and no/neutral, somewhat disagree, or strongly disagree to each question.

3. There is a rational explanation for everything, since events are produced according to physical laws.

4. Your thoughts and beliefs create your reality.

5. Reason leads us to discover the general truths and ideas that explain all existing things.

9. Reality is fluid and ever-changing; thus forever beyond the grasp of the rigid, abstract concepts & categories of our thought and language.

10. Ultimately, the universe is made of solid and indivisible particles.

11. The universe is unfolding according to a divine plan and order.

13. Spirit or mind creates the world, and all our science can only describe the effects after-the-fact.

15. Psychic abilities exist, proving mind over matter.

20. Our personal souls will survive death, and perhaps be back on earth for another go-round.

22. I am not a number, I am a free man! (or woman)

24. As Plato proved, a child has innate knowledge of mathematics; therefore eternal and rational truths exist.

28. There are universal symbols and archetypes that keep appearing in our experience.

29. Mathematics is probably one of the closest things to truth you can find.

31. By transcending the delusions of your thinking mind, you discover that you are not a separate ego, but are one with a greater being.

32. This is the best of all possible worlds; seen from God's viewpoint, all evil fits into a greater good.

33. God does not exist.

Indicate your answers here by circling your score for each question in the appropriate box. Where two scores are listed, circle both.
strongly agree somewhat agree yes&no/neutral somewhat disagree strongly disagree
3. 3R  3M 2R  2M 2E  2S 3E  3S
4.       4S       2S       2M       4M
5. 4R  2R 2E 4E
9. 4E 2E 2R 4R
10.     4M       2M       2S       4S
11.3R 3S 2R  2S 2E  2M 3E  3M
13.     4S       2S       2M       4M
15.      4S       2S       2M       4M
20.      4S       2S       2M       4M
22.3E  2S 2E  1S 2R  1M 3R  2M
24.4R 2R 2E 4E
28.3R  2S 2R  1S 2E  1M 3E  2M
29.4R 2R 2E 4E
31.2E  4S 1E  2S 1R  2M 2R  4M
32.      4S       2S       2M       4M
33.      4M       2M       2S       4S

Add your circled scores here:
___E ___S ___E ___S ___E ___S ___E ___S
___R ___M ___R ___M ___R ___M ___R ___M

Then add all the E scores across the columns above  _______
Then all the S scores ________
Then all the R scores ________
Then all the M scores ________

Write the larger letter scores above the smaller letter scores here:
 
          E and R           S and M
          _______          ________
 minus _______ minus ________
equals _______ equals ________
Write the letter corresponding to the larger score next to the result. The left column is your E/R score and the right column is your S/M score.

For example:
 
        E and R         S and M
           20E            20S
minus  10R minus  10M
equals 10E equals  10S

The meaning of the scores: what are your metaphysics?
1-9 R = somewhat intellectual; general, rational truths are real; fluid, changing experiences are mere momentary reflections of them
10-18 R = definitely intellectual
19-27 R = extremely intellectual
1-9 E = somewhat experiential;  the changing flow of being is real; abstract, intellectual categories are mere reflections of them
10-18 E = definitely experiential
19-27 E = extremely experiential
1-14 S = somewhat spiritualist;   Spiritual realities are prior to and explain material ones
15-28 S = definitely spiritualist
29-42 S = extremely spiritualist
1-14 M = somewhat materialist;  Material realities are prior to and explain spiritual ones
15-28 M = definitely materialist
29-42 M = extremely materialist

If you are R and S, you are essentialist: universal ideas and archetypes are primary reality
If you are R and M, you are rationalist: the universe operates according to causal, logical laws
If you are E and S, you are existentialist: spontaneous flux of inner being is the primary reality
If you are E and M, you are empiricist: the concrete, tangible and sensible is the most real

The approach to reality shown by your score matches these Jungian functions and MBTI temperaments, although your temperament itself may be different:

R/S essentialist = N intuitive
R/M rationalist = T thinking
E/S existentialist = F feeling
E/M empiricist = S sensing

Your score places you in one of 32 quadrants. A circle can be drawn around them. This is the subsidiary Circle of Metaphysics. Here I will only show the quadrants. Imagine a circle around them.

I have used most of the same 2 defining keywords for each quadrant as in the overall circle, and shown philosophers and traditions who I think may occupy them (positions are necessarily approximate). The quadrants in the opposite positions to each other, and same distance from the center, have opposite and complementary meanings.
 
29-42S
10-19R
Asceticism
Abstraction
Augustine
29-42S
0-9R
Esoterics
Revelation
Metaphysics
Plotinus
29-42S
0-9E
Spiritism
Psychism
Mysticism
Jesus
29-42S
10-19E
Transcendence
Solipcism
Berkeley
Kierkegaard
15-28S
19-27R
Essence
Forms
Plato
Pythagoras
15-28S
10-18R
Truth
Eternal values
Principles
Classicism
Leibniz
15-28S
0-9R
Theology
Theosophy
Hegel
Aquinas
Jung
Kant
15-28S
0-9E
Aspiration
Faith
Teilhard de Chardin
15-28S
10-18E
Awareness
Awe
Romanticism
Schopenhauer
Buddha
James
Alan Watts
Jos.Campbell
15-28S
19-27E
Existence
Becoming
Bergson
Heidegger
Heraclitus
0-14S
19-27R
Order
Doctrine
Parmenides
Spinoza
0-14S
10-18R
Purpose
Ideals
Epictetus
Stoicism
Aristotle
0-14S
0-9R
Theory
Ideas
Whitehead
0-14S
0-9E
Reverence
Indefinite
Pantheists
Neo-pagans
Quantum Theory
0-14S
10-18E
Flux
Uncertainty
Authenticity
0-14S
19-27E
Nihilism
Absurdity
Nietzsche
Sartre
0-14M
19-27R
Formulae
Mathematics
Descartes
0-14M
10-18R
Calculation
Structure
Empedocles
0-14M
0-9R
Explanability
Manipulation
Voltaire
Einstein
G.E.Moore
0-14M
0-9E
Pragmatism
Utilitarianism
Mill
Bentham
Anaxagoras
0-14M
10-18E
Relativism
Chance
Skeptics
0-14M
19-27E
Chaos
Nominalism
Hume
15-28M
19-27R
Logic
Geometry
Euclid
15-28M
10-18R
Natural Law
Reliability
Mechanics
Hawking
 
15-28M
0-9R
Predictability
Causality
Freud
Russell
Marx
Santayana
15-28M
0-9E
Verifiability
Secularism
Dewey
Carnap
Locke
15-28M
10-18E
Sophism
Evidence
Appearances
15-28M
19-27E
Sense-
Perception
Wittgenstein--
(later years)
29-42M
10-19R
Necessity
Automism
Newtonian-- Physics
29-42M
0-9R
Atomism
Determinism
Hobbes
Democritus
29-42M
0-9E
Positivism
Objectivism
Darwin
Lucretius
Epicureans
29-42M
10-19E
Tangibility
Carnality
Bacon
Skinner


Ethics and Values This area of philosophy concerns right and wrong, good and bad. How should I guide my life? Are there standards of right and wrong? What kinds of experiences are worthwhile? What is the purpose and meaning of life? To find out your views about ethics, answer these questions, and then score your answers below, just like you did for the overall test.

1. The Heart has its reasons, which Reason does not know.

4. Your thoughts and beliefs create your reality.

6. If you would know the truth of life, look inward into yourself.

7. Since we're all different, and times change, there can't be universal standards of right and wrong.

8. Do not seek your treasure in the things of this world, but only in the eternal things.

12. A human has no fixed character, but only a history; you must choose your character and meaning of life.

17. Act on moral principles as best you know them, rather than yielding to the temptations and passions of the moment.

18. With understanding and clear, logical thinking, you can solve almost any problem and increase your control of events.

19. You can't wait until you have the answers; you're not fully alive unless you are taking a risk.

21. The soul can only be free by overcoming the body.

22. I am not a number, I am a free man! (or woman)

25. Human history is largely explanable in terms of economic and technological conditions.

26. The best way to live is to follow the delightful energies of the body. Reason is only the outer bounds of energy.

32. This is the best of all possible worlds; seen from God's viewpoint, all evil fits into a greater good.

Indicate your answers here by circling your score for each question in the appropriate box. Where two scores are listed, circle both.
strongly agree somewhat agree yes&no/neutral somewhat disagree strongly disagree
1. 4E  2S 2E  1S 2R  1M 4R  2M
4.       4S       2S       2M       4M
6. 1E  4S 1E  2S 1R  2M 1R  4M
7. 4E 2E 2R 4R
8. 2R  4S 1R  2S 1E  2M 2E  4M
12.4E 2E 2R 4R
17.4R 2R 2E 4E
18.4R 2R 2E 4E
19.4E 2E 2R 4R
21.2R  4S 1R  2S 1E  2M 2E  4M
22.3E  2S 2E  1S 2R  1M 3R  2M
25.      4M       2M        2S       4S
26.4E  2M 2E  1M 2R  1S 4R  2S
32.      4S       2S       2M       4M

Add your circled scores here:
___E ___S ___E ___S ___E ___S ___E ___S
___R ___M ___R ___M ___R ___M ___R ___M

Then add all the E scores across the columns above  _______
Then all the S scores ________
Then all the R scores ________
Then all the M scores ________

Write the larger letter scores above the smaller letter scores here:
 
          E and R           S and M
          _______          ________
 minus _______ minus ________
equals _______ equals ________
Write the letter corresponding to the larger score next to the result. The left column is your E/R score and the right column is your S/M score.

For example:
 
        E and R         S and M
           30E            20S
minus  20R minus  10M
equals 10E equals  10S

The meaning of the scores: what is your ethical philosophy?
1-12 R = somewhat intellectual; You rely on rational moral principles, and distrust feelings and experiences as unreliable guides
13-24 R = definitely intellectual
25-36R = extremely intellectual
1-12 E = somewhat experiential;  You rely on your feelings and experience to guide you, and distrust rational principles as relative or constricting
13-24 E = definitely experiential
25-36 E = extremely experiential
1-10 S = somewhat spiritualist;   Spiritual pursuits are more worthwhile than material ones
11-20 S = definitely spiritualist
21-30 S = extremely spiritualist
1-10 M = somewhat materialist;  Material pursuits are more worthwhile than spiritual ones
11-20 M = definitely materialist
21-30 M = extremely materialist

If you are R and S, you are essentialist: eternal, divine principles are the highest values
If you are R and M, you are rationalist: you live according to reliable and logical, predictable methods
If you are E and S, you are existentialist: you follow your feelings and insist on freedom
If you are E and M, you are empiricist: you seek the delights and securities of the world and the flesh

The approach to thinking shown by your score matches these Jungian functions and MBTI temperaments, although your temperament itself may be different:

R/S essentialist = N intuitive
R/M rationalist = T thinking
E/S existentialist = F feeling
E/M empiricist = S sensing

Your score places you in one of 32 quadrants. A circle can be drawn around them. This is the subsidiary Circle of Ethics. Here I will only show the quadrants. Imagine a circle around them.

I have used most of the same 2 defining keywords for each quadrant as in the overall circle, and shown philosophers and traditions who I think may occupy them (positions are necessarily approximate). The quadrants in the opposite positions to each other, and same distance from the center, have opposite and complementary meanings.
 
21-30S
13-25R
Asceticism
Abstraction
Augustine
21-30S
0-12R
Esoterics
Revelation
Metaphysics
Plotinus
Jesus
21-30S
0-12E
Spiritism
Psychism
Mysticism
21-30S
13-25E
Transcendence
Solipcism
Berkeley
11-20S
25-36R
Essence
Forms
Plato
Kant
Pythagoras
11-20S
13-24R
Truth
Eternal values
Principles
Classicism
Leibniz
Epictetus
Stoicism
11-20S
0-12R
Theology
Theosophy
Hegel
Aquinas
Buddha
11-20S
0-12E
Aspiration
Faith
Inner guidance
Jung
Teilhard de Chardin
Kierkegaard
11-20S
13-24E
Awareness
Awe
Romanticism
Schopenhauer
James
Jos.Campbell
11-20S
25-36E
Existence
Becoming
Bergson
Heidegger
Heraclitus
Alan Watts
0-10S
25-36R
Order
Doctrine
Parmenides
Spinoza
0-10S
13-24R
Purpose
Ideals
Aristotle
0-10S
0-12R
Theory
Ideas
Whitehead
0-10S
0-12E
Reverence
NatureWorship
Pantheists
Neo-pagans
Quantum Theory
0-10S
13-24E
Flux
Adventure
Authenticity
0-10S
25-36E
Nihilism
Absurdity
Nietzsche
Sartre
0-10M
25-36R
Formulae
Mathematics
Descartes
0-10M
13-24R
Calculation
Structure
Empedocles
0-10M
0-12R
Planning
Manipulation
Voltaire
Einstein
G.E.Moore
0-10M
0-12E
Pragmatism
Utilitarianism
Mill
Bentham
Anaxagoras
Epicurus
0-10M
13-24E
Relativism
Chance
Skeptics
0-10M
25-36E
Chaos
Iconoclasm
Nominalism
Hume
11-20M
25-36R
Logic
Geometry
Euclid
11-20M
13-24R
Natural Law
Reliability
Mechanics
Hawking
 
11-20M
0-12R
Prediction
Engineering
Freud
Russell
Marx
Santayana
11-20M
0-12E
Verification
Secularism
Experiment
Dewey
Carnap
11-20M
13-24E
Sophism
Evidence
Locke
Epicureans
11-20M
25-36E
Sense-
Perceptibility
Wittgenstein--
(later years)
21-30M
13-25R
Necessity
Automism
Newtonian-- Physics
21-30M
0-12R
Atomism
Determinism
Hobbes
Democritus
21-30M
0-12E
Positivism
Objectivism
Darwin
Lucretius
21-30M
13-25E
Tangibility
Carnality
Bacon
Skinner


If you want more information, or help with scoring, you can email me at eameece@california.com
See also Philosophy on a Circle (link below)
If you want further clarification and explanation of the questions, try this article
Please, if you care to, email me your score and any comments on the questionnaire.

BACK to overall questionnaire
BACK to Index
Back to Philosophy on a Circle